CSA and the Safety Measurement System: BASICs and thresholds
FMCSA's SMS ranks carriers in seven BASICs, prioritizing those at or above 50 to 80 percent thresholds. The 2024 enhanced SMS had no launch date announced as of 13 November 2026.

CSA is the Compliance, Safety, Accountability program of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), and the Safety Measurement System (SMS) is the tool FMCSA has used since December 2010 to identify motor carriers for safety interventions. SMS measures each carrier’s on-road performance from inspection violations and crashes and ranks it as a percentile in seven Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (BASICs). A carrier can be prioritized when a percentile reaches the Intervention Threshold, which ranges from 50 to 80 percent depending on the BASIC and the type of carrier, or when an investigation finds acute or critical violations. An enhanced SMS with seven “compliance categories” was announced on November 20, 2024; as of 13 November 2026 its launch date has not been announced.
Status: 13 November 2026. This page follows the two notices FMCSA has published in the Federal Register in docket FMCSA-2022-0066: the proposal of February 15, 2023 (88 FR 9954), which also describes the SMS in use at that time, and the notice of November 20, 2024 (89 FR 91874), which announces the enhanced SMS and answers the comments on the proposal. The Federal Register search of 13 November 2026 lists no other document in that docket and no FMCSA notice announcing the launch. This page gives the federal system only; the SMS Methodology and the Foundational Document that the notices refer to, and the SMS website itself, are not described here.
| Item | What the notices say | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Program | FMCSA’s Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) program | 88 FR 9955 |
| System | Safety Measurement System (SMS), implemented in December 2010 “to identify high risk motor carriers for investigations” | 88 FR 9955; 89 FR 91874 |
| Data | Motor Carrier Management Information System (MCMIS): violations found during inspections, traffic enforcement and investigations, plus crash and motor carrier census data | 88 FR 9955 |
| Categories | Seven BASICs, each with its own percentile | 88 FR 9955, 9959 |
| Intervention Thresholds | 50 to 80 percent, by BASIC and by passenger, hazardous materials (HM) or property carrier | 88 FR 9959 |
| Updates | Results calculated and posted once a month | 89 FR 91874, 91880 |
| Public data | Passenger carriers’ percentiles and alerts are public; property carriers’ are not; inspection, investigation, crash and registration data are public for all carriers | 89 FR 91874 |
| Enhanced SMS | Announced November 20, 2024; the BASICs become seven compliance categories | 89 FR 91874–91875; 88 FR 9956 |
| Launch date | To be announced in a follow-up Federal Register notice; none in the Federal Register as of 13 November 2026 | 89 FR 91880 |
What is the Safety Measurement System?
SMS is FMCSA’s system for choosing which motor carriers get a safety intervention. The 2024 notice summarises its uses: FMCSA implemented it in December 2010 to identify high risk carriers for investigations, and “FMCSA and its State enforcement partners also use SMS to identify and prioritize motor carriers for inspections and less resource-intensive interventions, such as automated warning letters” (89 FR 91874, section I). Section 5305(a) of the Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act of December 4, 2015 requires FMCSA to ensure, at a minimum, that a review is conducted on motor carriers that are among the highest risk carriers for 4 consecutive months according to their performance data.
SMS quantifies a carrier’s safety performance with the data in MCMIS, FMCSA’s motor carrier database. The February 2023 notice reports two results of FMCSA’s SMS Effectiveness Test, first published in 2014 and updated in 2018: carriers that SMS identified for intervention in one or more BASICs had a crash rate 61 percent higher than carriers not identified, and carriers that met FMCSA’s high risk criteria had a crash rate 178 percent higher than the national average (88 FR 9955).
Registration with FMCSA, the USDOT number and the New Entrant Safety Assurance Program that a new carrier goes through are described in USDOT number, MC number, UCR, IRP and IFTA. The 2024 notice names that program among FMCSA’s other enforcement tools: “the New Entrant program includes a safety audit on all new carriers entering in interstate commerce operations” (89 FR 91878).
The seven BASICs and their intervention thresholds
FMCSA prioritizes carriers for safety interventions “when their SMS percentiles reach or exceed pre-established levels called Intervention Thresholds” (88 FR 9959). Because “higher percentiles represent worse safety performance”, a lower threshold is the more stringent one. FMCSA’s Effectiveness Test found that the Unsafe Driving, Crash Indicator and HOS Compliance BASICs “have the strongest correlation to crash risk”, and those three have the lowest thresholds.
| BASIC | Property carriers | HM carriers | Passenger carriers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unsafe Driving | 65% | 60% | 50% |
| Crash Indicator | 65% | 60% | 50% |
| Hours of Service (HOS) Compliance | 65% | 60% | 50% |
| Vehicle Maintenance | 80% | 75% | 65% |
| Controlled Substances/Alcohol | 80% | 75% | 65% |
| Driver Fitness | 80% | 75% | 65% |
| HM Compliance | 80% | 80% | 80% |
These are the thresholds the February 2023 notice states as current. The enhanced SMS, which would change some of them, has no launch date announced in the Federal Register as of 13 November 2026.
What the two notices say about the individual BASICs:
- Unsafe Driving and Crash Indicator. Carriers are compared by whether they mainly operate Combination vehicles or Straight vehicles, so that each is measured against carriers with similar exposure to crash risk. A Utilization Factor adjusts for carriers with higher-than-average exposure, measured in vehicle miles traveled (VMT) per power unit (PU); it currently covers carriers that drive up to 200,000 VMT per PU per year (88 FR 9957–9959).
- Crash Indicator. It applies severity weights to reportable crashes and places more weight on crashes involving an injury or fatality, or the release of hazardous materials, than on tow-away crashes. FMCSA studied raising the minimum number of crashes needed for a percentile from two to three and decided against it. Crashes reviewed under FMCSA’s Crash Preventability Determination Program and found Not Preventable “will continue to be excluded from the prioritization methodology” (88 FR 9960).
- HOS Compliance, Vehicle Maintenance and Driver Fitness. SMS assigns percentiles in these three if the last inspection in the past two years resulted in a violation (88 FR 9959). The rules behind the HOS BASIC are in hours of service for truck and bus drivers.
- Driver Fitness. The 2024 notice describes the Driver Fitness Compliance Category as one that “covers driver requirements for the safe operation of CMVs, including training, experience, licensing, and medical qualifications” (89 FR 91879). The medical side is described in the DOT physical and the medical examiner’s certificate.
- Vehicle Maintenance. It is the largest BASIC, both in the number of violation identifiers it includes and in the number of violations cited during inspections (88 FR 9957).
- Controlled Substances/Alcohol. It has the fewest violations of any BASIC, and those violations are cited relatively infrequently (88 FR 9957). The testing rules are in the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse.
- HM Compliance. The current BASIC compares cargo tank carriers with non-cargo tank carriers (88 FR 9958). Placarding and the driver’s hazmat endorsement are covered in hazmat placards and the hazmat endorsement.
How SMS percentiles are calculated
SMS uses violations and crashes to calculate a “measure” of a carrier’s safety performance. It then places carriers in safety event groups by their number of inspections and crashes, and gives each carrier a percentile rank that compares its measure with the others in the same group. In the HOS Compliance BASIC, for example, carriers with 3 to 10 driver inspections are compared with each other, carriers with 11 to 20 with each other, and so on. Each violation carries a severity weight on a scale of 1 through 10 that is intended to correlate with its crash risk (88 FR 9958).
The 2023 notice shows how a percentile can move when a carrier changes group. In its example, a carrier with 10 inspections has a measure of 1.51 and a percentile of 53.0%; after one more inspection with no violations its measure falls to 1.37, but in the next safety event group its percentile rises to 75.0% (88 FR 9959).
A percentile is one of two routes to prioritization. The other is the result of an investigation: “A carrier can be prioritized for interventions because its percentile is at or above the Intervention Threshold and/or it has one or more A/C violations related to a particular BASIC” (88 FR 9955), A/C standing for Acute and/or Critical violations found during investigations.
Who can see CSA scores?
The notices speak of measures and percentiles; a commenter quoted in the 2024 notice calls them “CSA SMS scores” (89 FR 91879). FMCSA posts SMS results on its public website once a month. What the public can see depends on the type of carrier:
- Property carriers. “Under section 5223 of the FAST Act, FMCSA removed SMS percentiles and alerts from the public SMS website for motor carriers transporting property” (89 FR 91874, section I).
- Passenger carriers. Their percentiles and alerts remain publicly available.
- All carriers. Inspection, investigation, crash and registration data remain public.
Complete prioritization results are available to motor carriers and enforcement personnel logged into the SMS website. “Logged-in motor carriers can only view their own data, while logged-in enforcement users can view safety data for all carriers” (89 FR 91880, section IV.2). Details of individual violations are shown in the Inspection History tab, and the 2024 notice states that the new violation groups will not change the level of violation information available (89 FR 91877).
The enhanced SMS: what FMCSA announced in November 2024
On February 15, 2023 FMCSA proposed seven changes to SMS and opened a 90-day preview and comment period (88 FR 9954). During the preview, carriers could log in to a Prioritization Preview site to see their own results under the proposed methodology. FMCSA received 176 comments, and the comment period ended on May 16, 2023. On November 20, 2024 it published a notice that “announces enhancements to the Safety Measurement System (SMS)” and responds to the comments on each of the seven changes: reorganized categories with new segmentation, consolidated violations, simplified severity weights, proportionate percentiles, changed Intervention Thresholds, a greater focus on recent violations and an updated Utilization Factor (89 FR 91874).
The 2023 proposal would have renamed the BASICs “safety categories”. Three commenters asked for another term, and FMCSA “has decided to move forward with ‘compliance categories’ instead of ‘safety categories’ as this will provide simpler and more relatable terminology” (89 FR 91875). The 2024 notice responds to each change but does not print the complete new methodology; the details below come from the 2023 proposal unless the 2024 notice is named.
| Element | Current SMS | Enhanced SMS (proposed 2023, announced 2024) |
|---|---|---|
| Categories | Seven BASICs | Seven compliance categories: Unsafe Driving; Crash Indicator; HOS Compliance; Vehicle Maintenance; Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed; HM Compliance; Driver Fitness |
| Drug and alcohol violations | Own BASIC, Controlled Substances/Alcohol | Moved into Unsafe Driving |
| Operating while out of service (OOS) | Placed in different BASICs according to the underlying OOS violation | All in Unsafe Driving |
| Vehicle maintenance | One BASIC | Two categories: Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed, for violations a driver may identify during a pre- or post-trip inspection or while operating the vehicle, and Vehicle Maintenance for all others |
| Violations | 959 violations used in SMS | Proposal: those 959 plus 14 more combined into 116 violation groups; 2024 notice: two pairs of overlapping groups merged and one new group, Operating While Prohibited, added; no new total given |
| Severity weights | Scale of 1 through 10 | 1 or 2: weight 2 for OOS violations and for Unsafe Driving violations that are disqualifying offenses under 49 CFR 383.51, weight 1 for all others |
| Percentiles | Ranked within safety event groups | Proportionate percentiles; safety event groups only set periodic benchmark medians |
| Recent violations | Percentile in HOS, Vehicle Maintenance and Driver Fitness if the last inspection in the past two years resulted in a violation | Percentile only with at least one violation in the category in the past 12 months; the 2024 notice applies this to HOS, Vehicle Maintenance, Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed, HM and Driver Fitness |
| Utilization Factor | Up to 200,000 VMT per PU per year | Up to 250,000 VMT per PU |
| Segmentation | Straight and Combination carriers in Unsafe Driving and Crash Indicator | Also in Driver Fitness; HM Compliance split into Cargo Tank and Non-Cargo Tank carriers |
On segmentation, the 2024 notice gives the criteria in a table: a Straight carrier has more than 30 percent of the total power units in its fleet in straight trucks or other vehicles, and a Combination carrier has 70 percent or more in combination trucks or motorcoach buses (89 FR 91876, table 1). The 2023 notice describes Combination carriers as those with “more than 70 percent of their total PUs” in combination vehicles (88 FR 9957). Under the 2023 proposal, a carrier counts as a Cargo Tank carrier if more than 50 percent of its inspections indicated that the vehicles were cargo tanks (88 FR 9958). The American Bus Association and Greyhound asked for motorcoaches to be compared only with other motorcoaches; FMCSA answered that of the 764,117 interstate carriers subject to its assessment, only 1,963 are considered motorcoaches, a subset it called not large enough for stable carrier-to-carrier comparisons (89 FR 91877).
Proposed changes to the intervention thresholds
The February 2023 proposal applied the current Vehicle Maintenance thresholds to both vehicle maintenance categories and raised the thresholds for HM Compliance and Driver Fitness, the two categories that FMCSA’s updated Effectiveness Test found to have the lowest correlation to crash risk.
| Category | Current | Proposed in 2023 |
|---|---|---|
| Vehicle Maintenance | 80 / 75 / 65 | 80 / 75 / 65 |
| Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed | Not a category | 80 / 75 / 65 |
| HM Compliance | 80 / 80 / 80 | 90 / 90 / 90 |
| Driver Fitness | 80 / 75 / 65 | 90 / 85 / 75 |
The 2023 table lists only these four categories. In the 2024 notice FMCSA answered a comment about the high thresholds for Driver Fitness and HM Compliance: “Adjusting the thresholds ensures that the Agency focuses its enforcement program on carriers with the highest crash risk” (89 FR 91878, section II.5).
For the enhanced methodology as a whole, the 2024 notice states that the group of carriers prioritized in any category has a crash rate of 7.77 crashes per 100 power units, “which is 10 percent higher than the current methodology”, against a national crash rate of 5.00 crashes per 100 power units for the same period (89 FR 91875). FMCSA also found that the changes would increase the number of carriers prioritized for intervention by 3 percent (89 FR 91876–91877).
Violation moves before the launch
The 2024 notice lists changes “put into effect in the preview, and in the current SMS methodology where applicable” (89 FR 91879, section IV.1). FMCSA moved one violation from Unsafe Driving to Driver Fitness and added another to Driver Fitness; both concern operating a commercial motor vehicle while prohibited from performing safety-sensitive functions under section 382.501(a) in the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse, and they form a new violation group, Operating While Prohibited. In February 2024 FMCSA moved 13 Vehicle Maintenance violations from the Lighting violation group to the Clearance Identification Lamps/Other group “in the current and preview SMS methodologies” (89 FR 91880).
When does the new SMS start?
The 2024 notice ends: “A follow-up notice in the Federal Register will announce the launch date of the enhanced SMS website” (89 FR 91880, section V). It also says that a webinar series on the changes will be announced on the Prioritization Preview website. Section IV.2 adds that FMCSA, which will keep calculating SMS results monthly, is exploring more frequent updates of the inspection and crash data shown on the SMS website, with its decision to come in the follow-up notice (89 FR 91880).
As of 13 November 2026 the Federal Register shows no launch notice. It lists two documents in docket FMCSA-2022-0066, the proposal of February 15, 2023 and the notice of November 20, 2024. A search of FMCSA documents published since November 21, 2024 finds none containing “enhanced SMS”, “compliance categories” or “SMS methodology”; the titles of the seven that mention the “Safety Measurement System” show other subjects, from the Crash Preventability Determination Program (December 4, 2024) to a proposed rule on English language proficiency and the out-of-service criteria (August 10, 2026).
How CSA and SMS came about
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| December 2010 | FMCSA implements SMS to identify high risk motor carriers for investigations (the notices cite 75 FR 18256 of April 9, 2010) |
| December 4, 2015 | FAST Act: section 5221 orders a National Academy of Sciences (NAS) study of CSA and SMS, section 5223 is the provision under which FMCSA removed property carriers’ percentiles and alerts from the public website, and section 5305(a) sets the review of the highest risk carriers |
| October 5, 2016 | Earlier proposed changes (81 FR 69185): moving certain OOS violations to Unsafe Driving, segmenting HM Compliance, focusing on recent violations and updating the Utilization Factor |
| June 27, 2017 | NAS report “Improving Motor Carrier Safety Measurement”: it found SMS structured in a reasonable way and made six recommendations, the first being to develop an Item Response Theory (IRT) model |
| June 25, 2018 | FMCSA sends its corrective action plan to Congress |
| February 15, 2023 | Proposal of seven changes (88 FR 9954); FMCSA decides not to replace SMS with an IRT model |
| May 16, 2023 | End of the comment period; 176 comments received |
| November 20, 2024 | Notice announcing the enhanced SMS and compliance categories (89 FR 91874) |
What this page does not cover
- The SMS Methodology, the Foundational Document and the violation lists the notices refer to.
- Challenges to inspection data through DataQs, and the Crash Preventability Determination Program in detail.
- Safety fitness ratings, compliance reviews and investigations, and the New Entrant safety audit.
- Use of SMS data by insurers, brokers or shippers.
- Roadside inspection levels and out-of-service rules, described in CVSA inspection levels, decal and out-of-service criteria.
- State programs and intrastate carriers.
Quick answers
- What does CSA stand for, and what is SMS?
- CSA is the Compliance, Safety, Accountability program of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). Its Safety Measurement System (SMS), in use since December 2010, identifies motor carriers for safety interventions: investigations, and inspections and less resource-intensive interventions such as automated warning letters. It works from FMCSA's Motor Carrier Management Information System, which holds violations found in inspections, traffic enforcement and investigations, as well as crash and carrier census data.
- What are the seven BASICs?
- The Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories of the current SMS are Unsafe Driving, Crash Indicator, Hours of Service (HOS) Compliance, Vehicle Maintenance, Controlled Substances/Alcohol, Driver Fitness and Hazardous Materials (HM) Compliance. SMS ranks carriers by percentile within each BASIC; in FMCSA's words, “higher percentiles represent worse safety performance”.
- What are the CSA intervention thresholds?
- As the February 2023 Federal Register notice gives them for the current SMS: 65 percent for property carriers, 60 percent for HM carriers and 50 percent for passenger carriers in Unsafe Driving, Crash Indicator and HOS Compliance; 80, 75 and 65 percent in Vehicle Maintenance, Controlled Substances/Alcohol and Driver Fitness; and 80 percent for all carriers in HM Compliance. A carrier at or above a threshold, or with acute or critical violations found in an investigation, can be prioritized for intervention.
- Are CSA scores public?
- Partly. Under section 5223 of the FAST Act, FMCSA removed SMS percentiles and alerts for motor carriers transporting property from the public SMS website. Percentiles and alerts of passenger carriers remain public, as do inspection, investigation, crash and registration data for all carriers. Complete results are shown to logged-in users: a carrier sees only its own data, enforcement users see all carriers.
- What changes with the new SMS?
- FMCSA's notice of November 20, 2024 announces an enhanced SMS; as of 13 November 2026 its launch date has not been announced. Under it, the BASICs become seven compliance categories: Controlled Substances/Alcohol violations move into Unsafe Driving and Vehicle Maintenance is split in two, with a new Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed category. Violations are consolidated into groups, severity weights go from a 1-to-10 scale to 1 or 2, proportionate percentiles replace safety event groups, percentiles in five categories require a violation in the past 12 months, and the Utilization Factor is extended to carriers that drive up to 250,000 vehicle miles traveled per power unit.
- When does the new CSA SMS start?
- No date has been announced. The November 2024 notice says that a follow-up notice in the Federal Register will announce the launch date of the enhanced SMS website. As of 13 November 2026 the Federal Register shows no such notice: in docket FMCSA-2022-0066 it lists only the February 2023 proposal and the November 2024 notice.
Sources
- Revised Carrier Safety Measurement System — FMCSA notice and request for comments, 88 FR 9954, FR Doc. 2023-02947 (Federal Register, February 15, 2023) — Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (Federal Register)
- Enhanced Carrier Safety Measurement System (SMS) — FMCSA notice and response to public comments, 89 FR 91874, FR Doc. 2024-27087 (Federal Register, November 20, 2024) — Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (Federal Register)
- Federal Register API: documents in docket FMCSA-2022-0066, and FMCSA documents published since November 21, 2024 that mention the Safety Measurement System (search of 13 November 2026) — Office of the Federal Register (federalregister.gov)